When Should an NCR be Issued & How to Resolve It?

Non-Conformance Reports (NCRs) are vital in quality management. They help organizations document and address issues when a product, process, or service doesn't meet the expected standards or requirements. 

An effective non-conformance process ensures that issues are resolved quickly and efficiently, preventing future errors. But when should an NCR be issued? And how should it be handled when one is raised? 

Below is an overview of when an NCR should be issued, where it comes from, and how to resolve it effectively.

When Should an NCR Be Issued?

An NCR is a formal document issued to address deviations, defects, or failures in processes, products, or services that do not meet established standards, specifications, or regulatory requirements. Understanding when an NCR should be issued, is essential to maintain product quality, prevent future errors, and comply with industry standards. Here are some detailed scenarios and conditions under which an NCR should be issued:

1. Product Non-Conformance

If a product fails to meet the design specifications, quality standards, or customer requirements, an NCR should be issued. Common causes for product non-conformance include:

• Defects in Materials: If raw materials or components used in production do not meet the required specifications, they can result in product defects. For example, if a metal part is found to be improperly heat-treated or contains impurities that would affect its functionality.
• Manufacturing Defects: Any issues that arise during the manufacturing process, such as incorrect assembly, missed steps, or improper calibration of equipment, can lead to non-conformance. For instance, a batch of electronic devices where soldering quality is substandard, could lead to an NCR.
• Design Flaws: Products that do not meet the initial design criteria or that fail functional tests should trigger an NCR. If a new product release doesn't meet the required performance standards, the design flaws must be documented and rectified.

2. Process Deviations

NCRs should also be issued when there is a deviation from the established process or procedures that could affect the quality or efficiency of production. This includes:

• Improper Execution of Procedures: If workers or departments fail to follow the established Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), such as skipping inspection steps or using incorrect tools, an NCR is necessary to document and correct the issue.
• Process Control Failures: If process parameters, such as temperature, speed, pressure, or chemical composition, are not within the prescribed limits, this could compromise the product's quality or compliance. For example, a plastic molding process where the temperature exceeds limits could result in defective molded parts.
• Out-of-Spec Measurements: If inspection or measurement tools indicate that a process is producing parts outside the specified tolerance range, an NCR must be issued to prevent further non-conformance.

3. Non-Compliance with Regulations or Standards

NCRs are often issued to address instances where the organization or its products fail to comply with legal, regulatory, or industry standards. Common scenarios include:

• Regulatory Violations: If products or processes do not comply with safety, environmental, or health regulations (such as ISO, FDA, or OSHA standards), an NCR must be issued to ensure the company addresses these violations before they lead to legal consequences.
• Quality Certifications: If an organization's quality management system (QMS) is not aligned with the certification standards, such as ISO 9001, an NCR is required to bring processes back into alignment. This can include failures in the auditing process or deviations noted during inspections.
• Failure to Meet Contractual Requirements: If a product or service does not meet the agreed-upon requirements in a contract with a customer or supplier, this is a serious non-conformance that should be documented in an NCR to ensure it is addressed and resolved promptly.

4. Supplier Non-Conformance

An NCR may also be issued when suppliers fail to provide materials, parts, or services that meet the agreed-upon standards. This could be due to:

• Substandard Supplies: If raw materials or components supplied by third parties do not meet specifications (e.g., incorrect material grade or size), an NCR should be issued to the supplier to inform them of the issue.
• Late Deliveries: In cases where suppliers fail to meet agreed delivery timelines, resulting in delays in production or project timelines, an NCR can be issued to document and address the non-conformance.
• Quality Issues with Incoming Goods: When goods received from suppliers do not conform to quality specifications, such as defective or damaged items, an NCR is used to report these issues and request corrective actions, such as replacement or refund.

5. Customer Complaints and Feedback

Sometimes, an NCR is issued based on feedback from customers who identify defects or issues in the delivered product or service. These complaints may highlight:

• Product Defects After Delivery: A customer receives a batch of products with missing parts, faulty components, or poor performance. This complaint should lead to the issuance of an NCR to investigate the root cause and resolve the issue.
• Performance Issues: If the product or service fails to perform as expected in the customer's environment or under certain conditions, an NCR can help address the problem and prevent similar occurrences in the future.
• Warranty Claims: If products are returned under warranty due to defects or non-conformance, this typically results in an NCR to ensure the issue is documented and analyzed for future improvements.

6. Internal Audits and Inspections

Internal audits and quality control checks are another significant source of identifying when an NCR should be issued. Audits may uncover:

• Non-Compliance with Internal Quality Systems: If internal procedures, such as production checks, documentation, or equipment maintenance, are found to be non-compliant with internal policies or industry standards, an NCR should be issued.
• Failure to Meet Pre-Determined Criteria: Routine inspections or audits may reveal that processes or products are not meeting the set standards. An NCR helps document these findings and ensures corrective action is taken.

7. Preventative and Corrective Actions

In some cases, NCRs can be part of a proactive strategy to avoid potential failures. If potential risks are identified—whether through trend analysis, preventive maintenance, or employee observations—an NCR can be issued as part of a preventive action plan to address the underlying risks before they manifest as a full-fledged non-conformance.

Where Can an NCR Be Issued From (and Who Can Issue Them)?

An NCR can be issued from multiple levels within an organization, and anyone responsible for monitoring quality and compliance can issue one. These include:

• Quality Control and Assurance Teams: Often, these teams are the primary groups responsible for identifying and issuing NCRs due to their oversight of production quality.
• Operations or Production Supervisors: Supervisors involved in daily operations are in a position to notice any deviations or non-conformances in the process.
• Suppliers and Contractors: If the non-conformance is identified in a supplied product or service, the responsible party (supplier or contractor) may issue an NCR to highlight the issue.
• Auditors or Inspectors: Internal or external auditors and inspectors who are conducting assessments of the processes or products may also issue an NCR based on their findings.

The person issuing the NCR should have sufficient authority and knowledge to properly assess the situation and determine the appropriate corrective action.

How to Resolve an NCR When One Is Issued?

Once an NCR is issued, it needs to be addressed quickly and effectively. The steps to resolve it typically include:

• Root Cause Analysis: Determine the underlying cause of the non-conformance. This step is critical to ensure that the issue is fully understood and that temporary fixes do not become recurring problems.
• Corrective Action: Implement corrective measures to fix the immediate non-conformance. This could involve reworking the product, adjusting the process, or updating procedures.
• Preventive Action: After addressing the immediate issue, it's essential to put in place measures to prevent the non-conformance from happening again. This might involve process changes, additional training, or system improvements.
• Verification and Validation: Confirm that the corrective and preventive actions have been implemented successfully and that they have resolved the non-conformance without causing further issues.
• Close the NCR: Once the corrective actions are verified, the NCR can be closed. Documentation should be updated, and the results of the resolution process should be communicated to the relevant parties.

By following these steps, organizations can effectively address non-conformances, improve quality, and ensure compliance with industry standards.

Non-Conformance Management Software: Making the Process Easier

Managing non-conformances manually can be time-consuming, especially as the volume of issues grow. That’s where non-conformance management software can make the process easier for you. Here’s how it can help streamline the process:

• Centralized Tracking: Software keeps all NCRs in one place, making it easy to track their status and resolution.
• Automated Alerts: Automatic reminders ensure that corrective actions are taken on time and no issues fall through the cracks.
• Data Analysis: This software comes with built-in analytics, allowing you to identify trends and root causes faster.
• Improved Collaboration: Teams can collaborate within the software, ensuring that everyone knows their role in resolving non-conformances.

By integrating non-conformance management software into your process, you can significantly improve efficiency, accuracy, and overall product quality.

Conclusion

Effectively managing non-conformances is key to maintaining high-quality products and services. By understanding when and why to issue Non-Conformance Reports (NCRs), organizations can address defects and deviations proactively. 

NCRs can come from various sources, such as quality control teams, production supervisors, suppliers, auditors, and customer feedback. Resolving an NCR involves root cause analysis, corrective and preventive actions, verification, and closure. 

Utilizing Non-Conformance Management software streamlines this process by offering centralized tracking, automated alerts, data analysis, and improved team collaboration, ultimately boosting efficiency, accuracy, and product quality.

Related Article

• Common Causes of Non-conformance in the Manufacturing Sector
• How to Manage Non-Conformance with QISS QMS System?
• How Can Training Programs Improve Nonconformance Management Skills?